|
|
发表于 2017-3-27 15:40:16| 字数 5,879| - 日本 亚太环通(Pacnet)有限公司
|
显示全部楼层
|阅读模式
本帖最后由 gamersmile 于 2017-3-27 15:47 编辑
随着华为3月24日正式在国内发布P10、P10 Plus，这两款手机在用户中的热度也是迅速提高。
拍照是P10宣传造势时主打的功能，甚至广告海报上就是一个大大的美女头像，外加一行人像摄影大师。
那么，这款手机拍照的真实表现如何呢？虽然我们能接触到满屏幕的国内媒体、评测工作室的文章，但总觉得是哪里不太对。
是了，原来是海军的功劳。你能看到的只谈优点、回避缺点的评测文章，无一例外是被公关掉的。
今天午饭谈到P10，觉得很多网友都关注实际的表现。于是我用谷歌搜了下外媒关于P10摄像头的专项评测。找到一篇相对客观的评测文章，刊登在Trusted Review上。
时间关系，我仅仅翻译了部分关于相机和续航的内容。原评测中还有关于外观和系统体验的部分没有翻。各位可以亲自点开参考。
这里摘录翻译一段其不足的地方，供各位关心摄像头的网友参考。
这里结合文章的结论，说说我的观点：
追求更好拍照体验的华为粉丝们如果不差钱的话，不妨考虑采用了f/1.8镜头的P10 Plus。
考虑到华为的尿性，目前仅有少量机型和颜色供应，线上预订的手机铁定是要等的，而线下实体店及各经销商普遍是加价200-300不等现货。您就根据自己对华为的感情和钱包厚度决定吧。
我的顺序是先译文，后原文。所有引用的图片截图自国外原网站，版权归Trusted Review所有！
评测摘译：
拍照部分：
P10在低光下还是不完美的，或者说拍出的焦外不够真实。
虽然P10不是我在低光下测试的性能最差的相机，但它同样与此价位最好的相机相差甚远。 夜间或昏暗条件下拍摄的照片可能会受到噪点的影响，并且看起来过度处理，特别是拍摄场景中有明亮光源（如路灯）的时候。
即使是在光线偏暗的环境（如酒吧等）中拍照，P10的成像细节也不如同等定价的顶级手机，如iPhone 7或三星Galaxy S7，来得丰富。这可能是受制于P10的f/2.2光圈--对一部售价超过500英镑的手机来说，这无疑是最明显的短板。相比之下，Galaxy S7的后置摄像头具有f / 1.7光圈，iPhone 7为f/1.8，Pixel为f/2.0。
较小的光圈也会影响相机创建逼真的焦外。目前还没有任何一部手机后置摄像头可以拍出真实的焦外，P10也不例外; 在更大的屏幕（译者注：比如电脑显示器）上观看图像时，您绝对可以留意到主题周围的瑕疵和轻微的扭曲。
考虑到这一点，我不得不认为，追求更好拍照体验的华为粉丝们如果不差钱的话，不妨考虑采用了f/1.8镜头的P10 Plus吧。
P10的自拍和人像模式可通过软件处理增强画质。华为在自带相机中增加了“人像工作室（Portrait studio），可以进行简单的照片编辑。当然这远远不能称为手机上的Photoshop，仅仅是提供了美肤及高亮等调节功能，目的是对照片进行适当处理，以便在朋友圈分享你的美好形象。
电池续航部分
P10电池大小为3200mAh ，不可拆卸。对五寸手机来说，算是较大的容量了。相比之下，Pixel手机电池容量仅为2770mAh。
早九点上班前将手机充满，作为主力工作手机日常使用一天，到晚上十点还有50%以上的电量。使用内容包括上下班途中听音乐、一小时游戏、接打电话、频繁使用社交媒体以及收发邮件。
Trusted Review也对P10进行了视频测试，其表现尚可。屏幕调至50%亮度、在线观看Netflix视频，每小时P10掉电8-12%。作为参考，其他我测试过的机型每小时掉电在10-15%之间。
游戏测试，玩Banner Saga一小时耗电15-22%左右，对电池压力较大。
我留意到，P10电池在休眠机制上出现了明显的问题。休眠机制可以在系统待机时将非核心进程关闭以达到降低耗电量的目的。安卓7.0系统休眠新增的功能是可以在省电前提下，保证后台进程可以不时连接数据网络。在其他运行安卓7.0系统的手机上，新版休眠机制可以使手机一晚待机最少仅损失3%电量；而同等测试条件下，P10通常一晚待机会损失20%的电量。
原文：http://www.trustedreviews.com/huawei-p10-review-camera-page-3
Huawei P10 – CameraThe P10 is the second phone to carry Leica’s branding on its camera. The dual-lens system pairs a 20-megapixel monochrome sensor with a 12-megapixel RGB sensor. Huawei claims the dual-lens system will offer buyers a variety of benefits, including better low-light performance, the ability to create a more realistic bokeh effects, and improved black-and-white photography.
There is some truth to the first claim, but the P10 still isn’t perfect in low light or at creating a true-to-life bokeh – a cool-looking effect where the camera creates heavily out-of-focus areas of the frame.
The P10 isn’t the worst performing camera I’ve tested in low light, but it’s far from the best at this price. Photos taken at night or in dim conditions can suffer from noise and look overprocessed, particularly when there are bright lights – such as street lamps – around.
image: 
Even photos in moderately dark placess, such as bars, don’t display quite as much detail as competing top-end phones such as the iPhone 7 or Samsung Galaxy S7. This is likely due to the P10’s f/2.2 aperture, which is sub-par for a £500-plus phone. By comparison, the Galaxy S7’s rear camera has an f/1.7 aperture, the iPhone 7 an f/1.8, and the Pixel an f/2.0.
The lower aperture also affects the camera’s ability to create a realistic-looking bokeh. No phone camera has managed to create an authentic-looking bokeh and the P10, too, falls short; you can definitely see blemishes and slight distortions around the subject when viewing the image on a larger screen.
With this in mind, I can’t help but think that Huawei fans looking for a decent camera would be better off shelling out the extra cash for a Huawei P10 Plus, which has improved f/1.8 lenses.
Outside of this, the camera is pretty good. The camera app is nicely reactive and I didn’t notice any significant lag when shooting. Photos taken on the P10 in decent light didn’t appear over-sharpened and colours weren’t distorted. All in all, the phone’s camera is more than good enough for taking a few holiday snaps for sharing on social media.
The rear camera can also record 4K resolution video at 30fps or standard FHD footage at 60fps. Recordings generally look decent, albeit shaky if you don’t have a tripod, though again, low light performance is an issue.
image: 
The addition of manual controls for the camera’s settings, custom monochrome portrait mode, and special “impact” filter, can be used to create nicely atmospheric black-and-white images.
The 8-megapixel, f/1.9 front camera also performs well in low light and is more than good enough for selfies – although, again, its low-light performance isn’t great.
The P10’s selfie and portrait capabilities can be enhanced with the use of its software. Huawei has loaded the camera app with a custom portrait studio that lets you do basic touch-up work. It’s far from Photoshop on your phone, but controls for enhancing skin tone and dynamic lighting, for example, work well enough to make even a hack journo look semi-human in photos for social media.
You can see a selection of sample photos taken on the P10 below.
image: 
In regular light, the camera is up to task
image: 
Images aren't over-sharpened
image: 
And look sharp enough
image: 
Dynamic range is an issue, however
image: 
Team Trusted at MWC, no filter; it's probably a good thing the P10's camera struggles to focus in low light...
image: 
The black-and-white modes are fun too
Huawei P10 – BatteryThe P10 is powered by a 3,200mAh, non-removable battery, which is pretty big for a 5-inch phone. By comparison, the Pixel is powered by a 2,770mAh cell.
Taking the phone off charge at 9am and using it as my primary work and personal phone, the P10 had more than 50% of its charge left at 10pm with regular use. Regular use entailed listening to music on the commute to and from work, an hour of gaming, making and taking a couple of calls, and constantly checking my social media and email accounts.
The phone also dealt with TrustedReviews' video-streaming test fairly well. Streaming Netflix with the screen set at 50% brightness, the P10 lost an average of 8-12% of its battery per hour, which is pretty decent. Competing phones I’ve tested generally lost between 10-15% of their charge running the same test.
Gaming put a bigger drain on the battery. An hour of Banner Saga cost the P10 an average of 15-22% of its charge.My only real concern about the P10’s battery is that Android Doze doesn’t appear to be working correctly. Doze is a useful background feature that reduces power consumption by turning off anything but critical processes when the phone or tablet isn’t being used. The new version in Nougat is, in theory, able to save power when the device is on the move, by making it access data only in intervals.
The feature is a great addition that lets other Nougat phones I’ve tested retain as much as 97% of their charge when left off the mains overnight. The P10 regularly loses as much of 20% of its charge when left alone overnight.
|
评分
-
查看全部评分
|
狗仔卡
离线
提升卡
置顶卡
变色卡
